I have an argument
to make.
Numerous
platforms are often abused and ridiculed in many media outlets – Christianity
is just one that has known its share of persecution over the centuries. This is
something we do know. As if the debate circuit wasn’t already heated and
crowded enough, there has been an extensive fall-out in the Christian – and
more recently home school sphere about the new ABC comedy GCB. Also adding their voices to the controversy has been a
presidential candidate, politicians and a conservative radio host plus a number
of retailers are either pulling their sponsorship or adds during the show. To
be upfront, most of you probably saw that I did watch its pilot episode, and being
a Christian, I didn’t find it offensive enough to be enraged by it because I chose not to take the characters
seriously. In no way am I meaning this post
as a defense of the show because at its worst it does paint a horrible picture
of Christians and those of us who are Christians should be able to recognize not
just how blatant that picture appears but also to take it in stride and realize
that this isn’t the only cultural issue that needs to be addressed.
Recently Michael
Farris (a founding member of HSLDA) wrote an article on the show, much of which
I have no wish to dispute but I would
also argue if we are being asked to essentially “shun” this show because of its disrespectful manner,
then we should in actuality stop supporting everything that comes out of
Hollywood. Watching movies or television shows has never been something I’ve
questioned in terms of giving up that small piece of delight all together – nor
is it something I am contemplating. My family was always very cautious about
what we saw growing up and in fact as a young girl, I didn’t watch all that
many movies, period. My mother encouraged us to be outside and to be
imaginative in our play time but with that said, as an adult, I have never
thought, “I really should stop watching movies altogether.” I know a family who
are very strict about what they see so they watch nearly no films and I don’t
have a problem with that at all if it is a conviction and something they feel
strongly about but then I’d also suggest to them to not watch anything: a.)
because they always find something bothersome about the context of the movie,
and b.) because there isn’t a movie out there that does not promote something
you as a moral viewer will disagree with (even if it is only bad-mannered
behavior).
It is true
that not every production mocks Christianity as GCB does but every mainstream movie actually does by going against
everything we condone and believe in, everything we teach our children is wrong. I get that is the real argument
with this show. At the movies anything and everything is “acceptable” as is
that same behavior almost expected in society. As a young Christian who still
has a lot to learn, I am not going to be swayed by GCB’s message. Knowing that, I do realize that the audience this is
targeting are non-Christians who already think all Christians are hypocrites. In
his article Mr. Farris made the point that if this were any other religion
being mocked there would be complete outrage, something I do agree with. Maybe
I am just dense, but I did not view this as anything worse than any of the
other PG13-rated movies I may have seen. Granted those don’t use the Christian
faith directly as a dart board but they do disregard everything righteous and moral – in spades, and in fact, glorify it.
Blatant
disregard of the marriage vows manifested in glorified adultery is just as big
of a “problem” as anything as are numerous other “sins” easily and proudly
depicted in movies or television and yet, there is not a crusade launched
against them. In our world today, what are politicians doing engaging in a
“debate” over something so trivial as a television show? Maybe it has the
potential to have a long-lasting impact but I seriously have my doubts. There
are so many more prominent and important issues
plaguing our world than a show – our freedoms is just one such issue. I realize
that most, if not all of you probably vehemently disagree with me, and that is
okay; I respect that. However, I have been a bit annoyed at the outrage over
this show when in fact there is a number of equally horrible programming out
there: Where is the disgust for that? Has anyone protested the sexually
promiscuous programs that air on Showtime Network? True perhaps this is the
only one that currently has airtime and is using Christianity as its target but
nevertheless, if we are going to protest one show, shouldn’t we examine and
question the rest of what is airing on our televisions?


































that show is so horrible. i saw some of one episode, then shut it off. my friend and i took the time to write to the sponsors and tell them that if they didn't stop supporting the show, we would stop buying their products. *sigh* i sure will miss dove deoderant ;)
ReplyDeletexo,
j
Personally, I think we should take more seriously things that stand against the name of Christ than things that are simply immoral. I actually gave up one of my all-time favorite shows for two years when they decided to become offensive in dealing with God and angel. I also took a lot of flack for that among some of my Christian friends who did not see it as I did -- but I did it because I felt convicted, and because God has warned us that "He will not be mocked." I don't think it is hypocritical to object to Christianity (and by that extension, Christ) being slandered but not voice the same objection about programs that are non-Christian but offensive. We cannot expect the world to have morals, but we do have the right to demand that Christianity be represented in a respeftul manner. Unfortunately, it never is. Either Hollywood takes it out (like that Sandra Bullock film everyone was raging about) or it is slammed, because Christ is hated. And so are we.
ReplyDeleteFor the most part, we all make compromises that we shouldn't in our entertainment. We (and this includes me, so I'm not pointing fingers) all "condone" things we shouldn't, just for a few hours of amusement. Every DVD or movie ticket we buy says, "We support this," but we still do it. Even so, I think we have to draw a line somewhere, and when it comes to maligning my Lord? Well, that's where I draw the line.
PS: Sorry about the typos. I'm on a different computer than usual, and my fingers can't figure out where the right keys are. =P
ReplyDeleteThis is a very interesting thought, Rissi, and I think I agree for the most part-- immorality is immorality and it is all offensive to God, no matter how you slice it.
ReplyDeleteHowever, I also have to agree with Charity. We as Christians should be especially concerned when Christ is mocked in this way. I've seen previews for this show and I was horrified. It's mocking Christianity, it is mocking Christ, and it is mocking His work on the cross. We can't speak out against every show on the network, but when the world is as open, blatant, and crude in their persecution of Christ and Christians as in GCB, I think we as Christians have to take a stand.
But I definitely see your point here-- and I agree that if we were to boycott all the shows that violated Christian morals in some way, we would have to boycott almost every show. I just believe that shows that are as pointed and deliberate as GCB deserve special attention as they are pretending to be in the name of God and thus have greater potential to lead people astray.
Thanks for your thoughts!
Jessica - I respect your opinion and understand just where you are coming from. This wasn't meant to be an argument to entice readers to watch the show, I just wanted to share my thoughts on it.
ReplyDeleteHa! Your comment made me smile about having to give up certain products - what is worse is when you just get attached to something and then the company discontinues it! That makes me mad. ;)
So glad you stopped in, Jess.
Charity - I don't disagree with that AT ALL. Living in America does give us the freedom to speak and promote what we like - still, that doesn't mean we, as Christians have to like what is being said. Like I said in my prior response, this post wasn't meant as a "vote" for this show, it was simply the inspiration behind it.
I am all for standing up for convictions - it is what we all should strive for. If someone feels uncomfortable in a situation or with a television program, well then, our conscious (the Holy Spirit) is trying to tell us something. I just do not believe that this show is going to have a lasting impact or "change" anything - and the fact that a presidential candidate joined in the debate is sad to me. There are far too many other things that bear time and attention. Knowing GCB mocks Christ is not something we should applaud but I also have just as many misgivings about "mere" immoral content. Every time it is promoted is just another disregard of God's Word - just one more way to say that it's "okay" for the world to continue living as they please. To pursue whatever makes them happiest.
In life (no matter the avenue) we strive to do the right thing (or that is my "motto" personally) but yes, unfortunately, we all make some compromises that are not wise. Hopefully, they are only "minor" ones and not something that will change our life. Using wise judgement is something we learn from experience so sometimes, it does take a wrong turn to live differently.
Typos: Eh! No biggie - have you seen some of mine!? =D
AnnaKate - I don't disagree with Charity's (or you) thoughts at all. However, what I am arguing is that this is not something we should be debating at this point in time. Politician's should put their minds to "fixing" other more important things. As it stands right now, I do not believe this show is going to have a lasting impact on anything - if it does, I am more than willing and ready to admit being in the wrong.
Being Americans (living in America) gives us the right to have free speech and speak out against something like this - and that is a wonderful privilege. Similarly the people in Hollywood have the right to say whatever they want. It doesn't mean I like it but I choose what I watch and what I don't - no one forces me to watch immoral movies or TV nor do they have a hold over influencing my opinions (or more specifically, the show in this post does not).
That is sad to think that there is next-to-nothing out there that is moral. It is just one reason why I hope companies like Sherwood Pictures among others succeed because it is so refreshing when we stumble across something that is inspiring rather than degrading.
*Thank you for your comments, girls - I appreciate and respect your opinions.*
The most common thing I've heard from those who object to the show is that they've gone "too far." Other shows may have Christians as minor or supporting characters that are mocked, or that act (like you said) immorally, blatantly going against Christian principles, but this show is different in that it has "Christians" as some of the main characters.
ReplyDeleteI agree that we can't really condemn a show like this without condemning a lot of shows. I think, though, that the reason some people refuse to watch this is that it's not at all subtle in its mockery. Which, of course, may be a bad thing since it's much easier to unwittingly accept subtle mockery than a blatant one.
I also agree that "there isn’t a movie out there that does not promote something you as a moral viewer will disagree with."
However, part of discerning viewing is being able to distinguish the good from the bad. To take the good and moral themes from a story, and being able to tell (and ignore) the bad and immoral ones.
Which, when you think about, is also how we need to live our lives. We need to be able to discern the bad and the good. Just like not all stories easily distinguish between the two, life doesn't always distinguish between the two. So we need to be discerning. :)
Thanks for the post!
I feel ya.
ReplyDeleteAt least with this show, you know what you're getting into ahead of time. Many shows have the guise of "family friendly" and exhibit all kinds of bad stuff.
Lauren - I think that is an accurate assessment of this show. Since watching the premiere, I've not really "kept up" with it in terms of reading about its progress.
ReplyDeleteGenerally, yes, Christianity is only mocked in subtle ways but don't you think that we (myself included) should be just as upset by that as the blatant kind? I do.
You are correct - being a viewer who uses discretion is the "only" way to watch movies. Being raised as I was, that is something that is easier for me to do than a 13-year-old who sees the same movie with a group of peers. It is sad that parents don't care more. Living life being able to make the right judgement call is what we all strive for - and I think despite the moments when we will stumble, that is achievable. =)
Juju - you are so right. The previews of this show never tried to be anything other than what it was. At least, that is something we can appreciate about it. Excellent point - far too many shows do that, and it is annoying!
*Excellent input, girls - thank you all for voicing your opinions.*